Pardon me for thinking that, unlike ivy, I die when I become attached.

--André Breton, The Lost Steps

Log In

Receive Updates via RSS

What is RSS?

Recent Posts

Topics


« Black Mountain at Lee’s Palace yesterday, March 5th | Main | Feasts »

Review: A Field Guide to Otherkin, by Lupa

By Psyche | March 9, 2008

Stumble it!

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

A Field Guide to Otherkin, by Lupa
Immanion Press, 9781905713073, 310 pp. (incl. appendices, bibliography, and index), 2007

A Field Guide to Otherkin is the first full length treatment of this subculture, and, as such, while it has an extensive bibliography, a significant amount of material is drawn from surveys submitted from Otherkin and Lupa’s own experience, as she identifies as Otherkin herself.

Otherkin are people who are physically human, yet believe some aspect of their being to be wolves, foxes, or even fae, dragons and other fantastic creatures. Where in totemism a connection has been forged with an external entity, Otherkin identify the “other” as a part of themselves.

Lupa defines someone who considers themselves to be Otherkin as “a person who believes that, through either a non-physical or (much more rarely) physical means, s/he is not entirely human. This means that anyone who relates internally to a nonhuman species either through soul, mind, body, or energetic resonance, or who believes s/he hosts such a being in hir body/mind”.1

As I mentioned earlier (see On Otherkin), I know several people who self-identify as Otherkin, some of whom contributed surveys intended for this field guide, but I’m not well aquainted with the subject. This book has certainly helped me sort out what someone means when they say they are Otherkin.

The first section of the book gives an overview of Otherkin, theories of origins, and introduces various types, such as therianthropes, vampires, elves, fae, dragons, grypons and other mythological creatures, and the miscellaneous. Indeed, some Otherkin don’t have words to describe how they view their “true selves” and may pick and choose among what’s known. Lupa allows that “[s]emantics may also have something to do with it; if a person possesses an intelligent but animal ‘energy’ that doesn’t quite resonate with mundane animals, s/he may be more likely to identify it with ‘dragon’ than the lesser-known ‘gryphon’”. However, she confers far greater credulity than seems reasonable when she writes that “[t]his may explain the influx of gryphon-identified Otherkin after the publication of Mercedes Lackey’s Valdemar series of fantasy novels, which featured intelligent gryphons.” That said, she also notes that “[s]ome say it was because the books served to Awaken more gryphonkin; others argue that it resulted in a lot more wannabes.”2

Lupa presents a surprisingly rational and balanced view of the subject. While a significant amount of space is dedicated to acknowledging and accepting one’s “‘kin status”, there’s also a great deal allotted to questioning who or what one is and why one would want to identify as something other than human.

Recognizing that “wannabes” can be a problem; she writes “Otherkin have, to an extent, become a fad. Like it or not, there are certainly those who simply latch onto an idea that appeals to them, but doesn’t fit them whatsoever. Rather than participating in the deep soul-searching that most serious seekers use, they instead try to find any excuse to prove their ‘kin side.”3 She offers suggestions for those who think they may be Otherkin, but aren’t quite sure, and advice on how to “come out” - or not.

I tried to keep an open mind when reading this book, but when the subject of “Mediakin” and “Otakin” arose - “those who identify with beings from movies, books and other media, though anime and manga tend to be the most common influences”4 - I couldn’t help but think that surely a line must be drawn somewhere? While she acknowledges scepticism by many, she affords “Mediakin” the same fair treatment, which, to my mind, undermines her presentation of the subculture to some degree. At what point do you call it?

The appendices include a note on Otherkin gatherings, Lupa’s completed survey, statistics from the collected surveys, and, interestingly, the results of an interview with Su Fenton, a professional with a degree is social work licensed in psychotherapy. Ms. Fenton indicated that were someone to come to her with this, she wouldn’t immediately label them with a “big diagnosis” were the individual able to express the ability to “think about it with complexity, to enjoy it, to sometimes get into it, to look at it with distance”. However, she states that she “might challenge some of it, maybe, how you perceive it, but you’re already open to the challenge”, but ultimately, she says, “whatever works as a metaphor for you and [is] meaningful, and it’s amazing.”5 In short, Otherkin who are able to function in the world with some success are unlikely to be thrown into small rooms with comfy walls wearing love-yourself jackets. Fear not.

A Field Guide to Otherkin offers an insider’s perspective on the subculture from a variety of voices, and proves a great resource for anyone wanting to learn more about it: suggesting balanced self-questioning for those who consider themselves Otherkin, while explaining what it’s all about to the non-’kin, ‘kin-curious.

Syndicated from SpiralNature.com:
http://www.spiralnature.com/reviews/book/lupa.html#afgto1

Posts Related to Reviews

  1. Review: Sacred Land, by Clea Danaan
  2. Review: Kaostar!, by Francis Breakspear
  3. Review: Our Gods Wear Spandex, by Christopher Knowles
  4. Review: As One Is, by Jiddu Krishnamurti
  5. Review: The Four Powers, by Nicholas Graham
  6. Review: The Satanic Scriptures, by Peter H. Gilmore
  7. Review: Green Hermeticism, by Peter Lamborn Wilson, et al.
  8. Review: The Thoth Companion, by Michael Osiris Snuffin
  9. Review: Magick on the Edge, edited by Taylor Ellwood
  10. Review: The Place of Enchantment, by Alex Owen
  11. Review: A Field Guide to Otherkin, by Lupa
  12. Review: Aleister Crowley and the 20th Century Synthesis of Magick, by Dave Evans
  13. Review: Fallen Nation, by James Curcio
  14. Review: Tarot for the New Aeon, by P.C. Tarantino
  15. Review: Practicing Conscious Living and Dying, by Annamaria Hemingway
  16. Review: Women of Power, by Jaq D. Hawkins
  17. Review: A Science for the Soul, by Corinna Treitel
  18. Review: John Dee’s Occultism, by Gyorgy E. Szonyi
  19. Review: On Being a Pagan, by Alain de Benoist
  20. Review: Enochian Vision Magick, by Lon Milo DuQuette
Footnotes:
  1. p. 26 [back]
  2. p. 35-36 [back]
  3. p. 55 [back]
  4. p. 202 [back]
  5. p. 276-277 [back]

Topics: Books, Media, Reviews | RSS Feed | Trackback URI

Similar Posts

  • On Otherkin

    • « Black Mountain at Lee’s Palace yesterday, March 5th | Main | Feasts »

    One Response to “Review: A Field Guide to Otherkin, by Lupa”

    1. Lupa says:
      March 9th, 2008 at 12:05 pm

      Graci; I’ve been anticipating your review! You’ve gone into more detail than many, which I appreciate it. I was curious to see how you’d review it, since you tend to have a particularly low tolerance for B.S., and there’s always the potential with the topic of Otherkin for it to be interpreted as utter fluff.

      On the Mediakin/etc. topic, you’re not the only one to question it–even Taylor called me out on some things when he was editing the text. While I have my questions regarding the concept, I wanted to try to be as impartial as possible, and since I was trying to do a pretty thorough overview of the community as a whole, I included the section on Mediakin.

      Again, thank you for the thorough, detailed review!

      [Reply]

    Comments

    Please share your thoughts - I love comments! By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/website in attribution.